Dog & Cat Treats Price Comparison
Compare 136 dog and cat treats from Dreamies, Lily's Kitchen, Whimzees and more — find the best price across UK retailers in one place.
Dog & Cat Treats price comparison UK
Treats occupy a curious corner of the pet food market: technically optional, yet practically essential for training, bonding, and dental care. What's striking when you look across the 136 products listed here is just how wide the price spread is — from 1 £ for a single pouch of Dreamies to well over 1 £ for premium functional chews. That gap isn't random. It reflects a genuine divide between impulse-buy snacks and purpose-built treats with real health credentials.
Dreamies dominates the most-compared end of the catalogue, and it's easy to see why: the price point sits well below the market median, and cats go reliably mad for them. But palatability isn't the whole story. If your cat or dog has a sensitive stomach, the artificial flavourings and colourings in many budget pouches can cause more trouble than they're worth. Lily's Kitchen takes the opposite approach — named meat sources (duck, venison, chicken), no artificial nasties, and FEDIAF-compliant formulations. You pay more per gram, but you know exactly what's going in.
Dental treats are worth singling out. Whimzees and the Lily's Kitchen Woofbrush range both use mechanical chewing action to reduce plaque — a genuinely functional benefit that justifies the higher price tag compared to a standard crunchy biscuit. If your dog's breath could strip paint, a daily dental chew is a far cheaper fix than a vet scale-and-polish. For cats, dry food already provides some abrasive action, but dedicated treats add an extra layer.
TRIXIE is the most represented brand in this catalogue with 21 products, yet it rarely tops the conversation — it's a solid, mid-range option that covers a lot of ground without excelling in any particular area. Dokas, meanwhile, punches above its weight on ingredient quality for the price. Worth a look if you're buying for a dog with grain sensitivities.
One practical note: treats should account for no more than 10% of your pet's daily caloric intake. It sounds obvious, but caloric density varies enormously — a single long-lasting chew can clock in at over 100 kcal, while a Dreamies crunchie is closer to 2–3 kcal. Pairing treats with a balanced moist food diet or wet cat food makes portion tracking much easier. Compare prices across retailers before buying in bulk — the per-gram cost difference between a 60g pouch and a multipack can be surprisingly large.
How to Choose the Right Treats for Your Dog or Cat
Not all treats are created equal — and the difference between a 60g pouch of crunchy cat biscuits and a functional dental chew isn't just price. The right treat depends on your pet's age, health needs, and what you're actually trying to achieve. Here's what genuinely matters when you're comparing options.
Named meat source vs. vague 'meat meal'
The first ingredient on the label tells you most of what you need to know. Named meat sources — chicken, duck, venison, beef — indicate a traceable, higher-quality protein with better bioavailability than generic 'meat meal' or 'animal by-products'. For pets with sensitive digestion or skin issues, this distinction matters enormously. Lily's Kitchen and Dokas consistently list named meats first; many budget brands do not. If the label says 'meat and animal derivatives' without specifying the species, treat it as a red flag for ingredient transparency.
Functional benefit: what is this treat actually doing?
There's a meaningful difference between a treat that's purely a reward and one that earns its place in your pet's routine. Dental chews (Whimzees Toothbrush, Lily's Kitchen Woofbrush) use abrasive chewing action to reduce plaque — vets broadly support their use as a supplement to brushing. Joint-support treats typically contain glucosamine or omega-3s and are worth considering for older dogs. If you're buying treats purely for training, palatability and low caloric density matter more than functional ingredients — a small, soft, smelly treat gets results faster than a hard biscuit.
Caloric density and the 10% rule
Treats should represent no more than 10% of your pet's daily calorie intake — a guideline that's easy to ignore and easy to breach. Caloric density varies wildly: a long-lasting chew can contain over 100 kcal, whilst a single Dreamies crunchie sits around 2–3 kcal. Low-calorie treats (under 5 kcal each) are ideal for training sessions where you're rewarding frequently. If your pet is already on a weight-management diet, check the kcal per treat before buying — the packaging doesn't always make this obvious.
Artificial additives and allergen profile
Artificial colours, flavours, and preservatives like BHA, BHT, and ethoxyquin are increasingly absent from premium ranges — and for good reason. Sensitive pets can react with itching, loose stools, or vomiting. If your dog or cat has known food sensitivities, look for limited ingredient diet (LID) treats with a single protein source and no wheat, soy, or corn. Grain-free doesn't automatically mean better, but it does reduce common allergen exposure. Always cross-reference the full ingredient list, not just the front-of-pack claims.
Texture matched to your pet's life stage
Texture isn't just about preference — it's a health consideration. Hard, crunchy treats provide dental abrasion and jaw exercise, but they're unsuitable for senior pets with worn or missing teeth, or puppies with developing dentition. Soft, chewy treats are gentler and easier to break into small pieces for training. Long-lasting chews (bully sticks, rawhide alternatives, Whimzees) provide mental stimulation and keep dogs occupied, but require supervision to prevent gulping. Match the texture to your pet's age, dental health, and how you intend to use the treat.
Price-per-gram: where bulk buying pays off
The sticker price on a treat pouch is almost meaningless without context. A 60g pouch at 1 £ and a 200g bag at 1 £ can represent very different values per gram — and the larger pack often wins significantly. That said, freshness matters: once opened, many treats oxidise quickly without resealable packaging. For single-pet households, a smaller pack that stays fresh beats a bulk buy that goes stale. Calculate cost-per-gram before committing, and factor in whether the packaging will keep the remainder in good condition.
- Everyday pouches (From 1 £ to 1 £) : This is Dreamies territory — small pouches, high palatability, and very little nutritional ambition. Fine for occasional rewards, but ingredient lists are often light on transparency. Miamor and some Inaba Foods products also sit here. Good for cat owners who want a reliable, fuss-free treat; less suitable if your pet has any dietary sensitivities.
- The sweet spot (From 1 £ to 1 £) : Most of the TRIXIE, Chewies, and 8in1 range lands here, alongside smaller Lily's Kitchen pouches. You start to see named meat sources, cleaner ingredient lists, and better portion sizing. This is where the best everyday value sits for most pet owners — enough quality to feel good about, without the premium price tag.
- Premium and functional (From 1 £ to 1 £) : Dental chews (Whimzees, Lily's Kitchen Woofbrush), larger Lily's Kitchen treat packs, and mid-range Dokas products occupy this band. You're paying for functional benefits, better ingredient sourcing, or larger pack sizes. Worth it if dental health or ingredient quality is a priority — less so if you're just after a training reward.
- Specialist and bulk (Over 1 £) : Schesir multipacks and bulk-buy formats dominate this tier. The per-unit cost can actually be competitive, but the upfront spend is significant. Schesir's average sits notably higher than most brands in this catalogue — it's a premium wet treat brand with a loyal following, but verify the per-gram cost before assuming it represents better value.
Top products
- Dreamies Turkey (Dreamies) : The most-compared treat in this catalogue for good reason — cats are reliably obsessed with it, and the price is hard to argue with. That said, the ingredient list is not something to scrutinise too closely if you care about clean nutrition. Best used sparingly as a reward, not a dietary staple.
- Lily's Kitchen Scrumptious Duck & Venison Sausages Dog Treat 70 g (Lily's Kitchen) : A genuinely good treat for dogs with chicken sensitivities — named duck and venison as primary proteins, no artificial additives, and FEDIAF-compliant. The 70g pack is on the small side for the price, but the ingredient quality justifies it. One of the better options in this catalogue for allergy-prone dogs.
- Whimzees TOOTHBRUSH (Whimzees) : The standout dental chew in this selection. The toothbrush shape isn't gimmicky — it's designed to maximise surface contact with teeth during chewing. Vegetarian, no artificial colours or flavours, and dogs tend to work at them for a satisfying amount of time. Not a replacement for brushing, but a meaningful supplement.
- Lily's Kitchen Woofbrush Dental Chew Large Dog Treat 50 g (Lily's Kitchen) : Premium dental chew with clean credentials — no artificial anything, and the chewing duration is genuinely long enough to provide meaningful abrasive action. Pricier per gram than Whimzees, but if your dog already eats Lily's Kitchen and you want ingredient consistency across their diet, it's the logical choice.
- TRIXIE 3178 dog / cat treat Salmon 110 g (TRIXIE) : TRIXIE's salmon treat is one of the better value options in the mid-range — 110g pack, fish as a named protein source, and a price that sits comfortably below the market median. Not the most exciting product in the catalogue, but a reliable, no-fuss option for owners who want a fish-based treat without paying premium prices.
Related categories
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I give my cat treats that are labelled for both dogs and cats?
Only if the product is explicitly formulated and tested as safe for both species — and even then, proceed with caution. Cats have fundamentally different nutritional requirements to dogs, including a critical need for taurine, an amino acid they cannot synthesise themselves. Some dual-labelled products meet both sets of requirements; others are dog treats with a loose 'suitable for cats' claim that doesn't hold up to scrutiny. Check the ingredient list for taurine if it's a cat treat, and never give a dog-only treat to a cat without verifying it contains no ingredients toxic to felines (xylitol, certain herbs, onion derivatives).
How many treats per day is actually safe?
The standard guideline is that treats should not exceed 10% of your pet's total daily caloric intake. In practice, this means knowing the kcal per treat — which isn't always printed prominently. A small cat on 200 kcal/day has a treat budget of just 20 kcal; a large dog on 1,500 kcal/day has considerably more headroom. Low-calorie training treats (under 5 kcal each) give you the most flexibility. If you're using treats heavily during training, reduce the main meal portion accordingly to compensate.
Are grain-free treats actually better for my pet?
Not automatically — grain-free is not a synonym for healthier. Grain-free treats replace cereals with legumes, potatoes, or tapioca, which can introduce their own issues. The more meaningful question is whether your pet has a confirmed grain sensitivity or allergy. If they do, grain-free treats make sense. If they don't, the absence of grains offers no proven nutritional advantage. Focus instead on named meat sources, absence of artificial additives, and overall ingredient quality rather than grain-free status as a shortcut to quality.
Do dental chews like Whimzees actually work?
Yes, with caveats. Dental chews with the VOHC (Veterinary Oral Health Council) seal have clinical evidence behind them for reducing plaque and tartar through mechanical abrasion. Whimzees and Lily's Kitchen Woofbrush are both well-regarded in this space. However, they supplement — they don't replace — tooth brushing. A daily chew will slow tartar buildup meaningfully, but a dog that never has its teeth brushed will still need periodic veterinary dental checks. For cats, dental treats are harder to administer and less effective than for dogs.
What's the difference between Dreamies and premium cat treats — is the price gap worth it?
Dreamies are cheap, effective at getting cats' attention, and widely available — but the ingredient list relies on artificial flavourings and offers minimal nutritional value. Premium alternatives like Lily's Kitchen use named meat sources, no artificial additives, and FEDIAF-compliant formulations. Whether the gap is worth it depends on how you use treats: for occasional rewards, Dreamies are perfectly fine. If treats form a regular part of your cat's daily intake, investing in cleaner ingredients makes more sense for long-term health. Compare the price-per-gram rather than the pack price — the difference is often smaller than it first appears.
Which treats are best for a dog with a chicken allergy?
Look for single-protein, limited ingredient diet (LID) treats with an alternative named meat source — duck, venison, lamb, or fish. Lily's Kitchen Scrumptious Duck & Venison Sausages and the TRIXIE salmon range are good starting points. Critically, check the full ingredient list for hidden chicken derivatives: 'poultry meal', 'poultry fat', and 'poultry broth' can all trigger reactions in chicken-sensitive dogs. Avoid any treat with vague 'meat and animal derivatives' labelling, as the source species is unverifiable.
Are cheap treats from lesser-known brands a false economy?
Sometimes, yes. The concern isn't price per se — it's ingredient transparency. Budget treats from brands without clear sourcing information may contain low-quality by-products, artificial preservatives like ethoxyquin, or undisclosed allergens. If a treat causes digestive upset, skin reactions, or your pet simply refuses to eat it, the saving evaporates quickly. That said, price alone doesn't guarantee quality: some mid-range brands like Dokas and Chewies offer solid ingredient credentials at accessible prices. Always read the label rather than relying on the price point as a quality signal.